The public is less accepting of charities using generative AI to communicate with supporters, particularly for personalised fundraising appeals, than other functions, according to new research by YouGov.
Its recent survey of 2,097 individuals in the UK found that 69% opposed charities using AI to create fictional stories or images showing examples of the types of people a charity helps, against 12% finding it acceptable.
Personalised donation appeals based on a donor’s previous giving also met resistance, with 59% of respondents finding it unacceptable and 14% acceptable.
Creating videos using AI-generated content got a similar response: 58% were opposed to it, and 16% found it acceptable.
Some 47% were against charities writing social media posts and website content with AI, compared to 26% who said it was acceptable.
Charities using chatbots to assist with responses to public enquiries and drafting AI-generated emails or images for fundraising campaigns were both opposed by 45% of respondents.
Using AI to create stories based on real experiences of people a charity had helped, with someone checking the content, split respondents, with 31% finding this acceptable, against 44% who considered it unacceptable.
YouGov said “resistance is strongest where AI could shape how donors are targeted or how a charity’s beneficiaries are represented”.
The survey shows the public was most accepting of generative AI when used behind the scenes to support charity staff.
Two in five respondents said it would be acceptable for charities to use it to summarise research or reports for staff and volunteers, compared to 32% considering it unacceptable.
Meanwhile, using AI to help staff write grant applications received a similar response, with nearly four in 10 finding it acceptable and a third finding it unacceptable.
However, there were no uses of AI that a majority of respondents found acceptable.
Gaps in charities’ AI skills and confidence
Separate research published by Charity Digital found that more than four in five voluntary organisations now use AI in their work but most use it experimentally rather than strategically.
Based on a recent survey of 118 people in the sector, the majority said their charity now uses generative AI, primarily for research and administration.
Respondents rated their own AI skills at five out of 10, with their leaders’ understanding at the same level, and trustees less confident.
Almost half described an open learning culture at their charities but more than a third called it “fractured”.
More than four in five were “cautiously optimistic” about AI while around a quarter were open to the technology but concerned about its impact on their charity and beneficiaries.
