Over a third of supporters have considered stopping giving to a charity because its messaging felt “guilt-heavy” or “pushy”, according to new research.
The Mind the Engagement Gap 2026 report, published today by digital experience agency Manifesto, says UK charities face a donor retention crisis, despite the majority of people believing that charities are essential.
Pressure is what puts off supporters most, the report says, with 34% citing “guilt-heavy or pushy messaging” and 30% saying they are asked for more money too often.
The report is based on two recent surveys conducted on its behalf – one with 1,626 UK adults supporting charities and another with 302 senior charity employees – with further contributions from charities such as Macmillan Cancer Support and Diabetes UK.
It says 85% of supporters are not growing their giving, with 44% of lapsed supporters citing affordability as the most common reason for stopping.
Asked what mattered to them, over 90% of supporters rated trusting that their support reached the cause and made a difference as important.
This was followed by “being in control of how I give and what I hear about” (81%) and “being shown what my support has actually achieved” (68%).
Fewer than half of supporters said they fully trusted charities and assumed they do good work, a figure falling to one in four among lapsed supporters.
Meanwhile, 28% of supporters said they had considered stopping support because of a news story or scandal.
While nearly two-thirds of supporters felt glad and proud when they last gave, only 49% were confident they had made a difference and 21% were unsure about their impact.
A third said they had considered stopping over how much goes to a charity’s running costs, and 22% thought too much goes to running costs and not enough to the cause.
Nearly one in four lapsed supporters said they would support a charity if they could see exactly where their money went.
Unwanted contact
Some 13% of supporters said they had considered stopping their support because a charity had contacted them in ways they had not agreed to.
On this, the report says: “Charities have built their contact around permission rather than preference. Once opt-in consent is in place, most charities aren’t asking what a supporter actually wants.
“The decisions about what data we capture and the tech systems that could hold those choices are owned and designed away from the teams who talk to supporters.”
Some supporters said they barely notice (24%) or avoid (9%) what charities send them.
Four in five respondents said it was important that charities do not “push for more than I can give before I’m ready”.
A majority also said they wanted charities to “speak to me like a person, not a donor to be processed” and that “they let me shape how often and what I hear about”.
Researchers also found that after their last gift, fewer than half of supporters felt appreciated for what they did, with 18% saying it did not really register and 8% that it felt flat or taken for granted.
They also found that only 30% of charities had recorded anything about a supporter’s motivations.
“Charities have been collecting supporter data to adhere to operational governance and to process gifts, not to understand people,” the report says.
“When personalisation exists, it’s grown up product by product with no one deciding how it should be used across the whole relationship.”