Investigation exposed VAT and cashflow issues at Charity Business
3 Feb 2012
An independent investigation into alleged financial irregularities at Charity Business has revealed that...
Andrew Hind has said there needs to be a better understanding of the Charity Commission’s willingness to allow payment of trustees, arguing that among larger charities “there is increasingly a case for many of those boards to have paid trustees”.
Speaking at the Russam GMS Annual Interim Management Summer Congress, Hind (pictured) said: “I think there’s a challenge for the Charity Commission to communicate better that there are all types of circumstances in which we are prepared to agree that they can remunerate their board.
“Otherwise you find it too difficult to attract the kind of skills you need, but also you don’t build really diverse boards with wide ranges of experience because the only people who serve on boards where you need a day or two a month are the people who can afford to do it.
“That’s why the vast majority of trustees are over 55, because they’re retired and they’ve got pensions, and I think increasingly we need to see a bit more change there.”
However, he ruled out removing the need for the Commission’s express permission to pay trustees, as “it would not be in the interests of the broader sector to have no controls at all”.
He explained: “How can you have a small fundraiser for a PTA or local environmental sector that raises 600 quid, and then say ‘there’s an honorarium attached to our board members and we all get 500 a year for sitting on the board’.
“You don’t need to do it, it’s counterproductive.”
Hind also addressed the issue of salaries for executives, saying the sector needs to be more honest with the public.
“The leading charities are themselves to blame for the fact that there is a general public perception that it’s unacceptable to pay competitive salaries for sector leaders.
“I say that because I think too many charities continually talk down the level of administration costs that is needed to run and lead complex charitable organisations.”
Sean
8 Jul 2010
Trustees need skills as well, as how else can they ensure effective governance and challenge the management when necessary.
I serve unpaid on 2 charities which both meet during the normal working week, but only because my employer allows me the time off, paid. If I had to have unpaid time off it would either take more than 50% of my annual holiday or a 5% pay cut to continue, neither of which is at all attractive, and I would drop out.
Saying that people should be passionate about something doesn't explain how a younger person with a family, a full time job and commitments of both time and money, issupposed to act as a trustee with no remuneration or rwrad, and funnily enough, that's why you see almost no one like that, just older semi- (or fully) retired types.
Ben
7 Jul 2010
In my opinion. Being a trustee of a charity is an honour, a big responsibility and something that individuals should be passionate about, passionate enough not to need remuneration. If a large charity needs specific skills, then recruit someone with those skills and pay them a salary, there is a direct conflict of interest if Trustees receive a wagee.
Clarifying trustee payments and expenses
Trustee payment survey - the findings
Existing governance model is 'bust', says RNIB chair
3 Feb 2012
An independent investigation into alleged financial irregularities at Charity Business has revealed that...
3 Feb 2012
Minister for employment Chris Grayling has confirmed that official statistics on the Work Programme, including...
3 Feb 2012
The Co-operative Bank has reaffirmed its commitment to provide charity credit cards following last week's...
3 Feb 2012
High net worth individuals take, on average, 36 days to decide whether to make a major charitable donation...
3 Feb 2012
Over £9m of an overall £20m has been awarded in the first window of the Social Action Fund to 16 projects...
2 Feb 2012
Charity sector self-regulation is ripe for expansion, according to the new chairman of the Public Fundraising...
31 Jan 2012
4Children has launched its new website to provide clearer information about its work and campaigns as...
31 Jan 2012
The European Commission has set out its proposal to reform data protection laws that would mean organisations,...
31 Jan 2012
Disability action charity Scope has revealed a user-led rebrand based on inspirational images submitted...

Attending our one day courses is a highly effective way of ensuring new and existing trustees fully understand their role, responsibilities and liabilities.
Ian Chisnall
Various Charities
Trustee
28 Jul 2010
At long last the CC have recognised that one of the barriers to getting representative boards with the right skills may be financial. Andred Hind is not obliging this change, but is signalling a major shift in attitude. Large national charities tend to attract people with resources, small local charities tend to attract people with time and interest. The middle ground is where the demands can be high because of the size of the organisations, yet the great and the good may not form a queue to serve in this capacity. It is here that some flexibility is vital and may help.
[Reply]