Existing governance model is 'bust', says RNIB chair 1

Governance | Tania Mason | 11 Nov 2009

The existing model of charity governance that gives non-executive trustee boards authority over executive staff is bust and cannot be sustained, the chair of RNIB told an audience of charity chief executives last week.

In a colourful and uncompromising speech to the Acevo annual conference, Kevin Carey said that boards should comprise both “non-executive wisdom” and “executive expertise and implementation” and that trustees should receive payment for their services.

Carey is in the process of setting up a Progressive Governance Association to promote professionalism among boards.  He used his platform at Acevo – where his chief executive at RNIB, Lesley-Anne Alexander, is chair – to outline some of his ideas.

“Things would be much easier and more efficient if the Charity Commission allowed boards to combine execs and non-execs in a co-creational process,” he told delegates. “The model which makes it difficult for beneficiaries to become trustees and which puts non-execs in a supervisory role over execs is bust.

“It should be obvious to anyone that the one thing non-execs can’t do is effectively monitor execs, especially in the area of finance and budgeting.  No director of finance is worth her salt if she can’t run rings around the honorary treasurer.”

Related to this, he went on, was the need to pay for strategic expertise, especially in the area of financial control. “Charities where the finance director can run rings around her honorary treasurer are running on their luck, and it won’t last forever.”

He said that while charities in general are not full of “venal and grasping people”, they are “prone to a level of vanity and grandstanding that commercial organisations would not tolerate”.

Carey also stated that the “whole regulatory framework of charities” should be reviewed so that they can meet the challenges that await them. “If government wants charities to be cutting edge, fleet of foot and flexible, it will have to take its foot off the regulatory pedal,” he said. “Sometimes small is beautiful but we need some national charities with the heft to compete in the commercial sector and to be taken seriously by government.  The DWP would not be able to ignore a disability charity with an annual turnover of more than a billion pounds.”

Share

Existing governance model is 'bust', says RNIB chair

Comments

[Cancel] | Reply to:

Sean Moran
Chair
16 Nov 2009

An excellent thought process Kevin. I have been on both sides of the coin as an exec and a trustee and I seen for far too long executives "manage" trustees who often don't have the time, or indeed the skills to effectively govern their organisation. We have seen what happens when it goes wrong with Age Concern, who will be next?

Minister denies music licensing change will cost sector £20m

11 Mar 2010

Minister for the third sector Angela Smith has been challenged to reveal the true cost to charities of...

Web users identify most postively with term 'responsible investment' says new report

11 Mar 2010

The term 'responsible investment' is regarded very positively with web surfers, while the term 'ethical...

Crisis in merger with smaller homelessness charity

10 Mar 2010

Crisis, the charity for single homeless people, is to merge with Off the Streets and Into Work.

£3m international development fund for local community groups

12 Mar 2010

A new £3m grant programme will encourage British community groups to improve links with communities in...

£5m worth of mini-grants bypass charities to young people

12 Mar 2010

Thousands of mini-grants worth £300 will be given out to directly to young people through a new initiative...

Minister denies music licensing change will cost sector £20m

11 Mar 2010

Minister for the third sector Angela Smith has been challenged to reveal the true cost to charities of...

CTT solution allows compliance with new payment card rules

11 Mar 2010

The Charity Technology Trust has partnered with BT to offer charities the first automated system for collecting...

New polio website takes historical approach

11 Mar 2010

The British Polio Fellowship has created a new website aimed at documenting the history of polio to help...

World Vision chooses remote working solution from Signify

10 Mar 2010

World Vision has opted for a hosted two-factor authentication (2FA) service from Signify to give mobile...

emailalert

Follow us on Twitter @CSgovernance
Training

Attending our one day courses is a highly effective way of ensuring new and existing trustees fully understand their role, responsibilities and liabilities.

>> Find out more <<