Sharp fall in fundraising complaints at most of the largest charities since the pandemic

16 Mar 2022 News

Over two-thirds of the largest fundraising charities saw complaints decrease after a dip in fundraising activity during the pandemic.

Civil Society News tracked complaints at the 50 largest fundraising charities over three years (2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21) to uncover the effect the pandemic had on fundraising complaints.

Charities must include a fundraising statement in their annual reports. This statement should include information about how they fundraise, how they protect vulnerable people, how they monitor third parties, and how many complaints they receive. 

Over the three-year period in question, the 50 largest fundraising charities together received almost 50,000 fundraising complaints. But the vast majority (over 20,000) of these complaints were before the pandemic began. Indeed, the pandemic had a drastic impact - with fundraising complaints decreasing to almost half of this by 2020-21. From 2019 - 2020 there were 18,582 fundraising complaints across the 50 charities, which dropped to 11,144 in 2020-2021. 

However, a third of the 50 charities surveyed saw an increase in fundraising complaints over the three year period. Charities told Civil Society News this was for various reasons – including receiving an influx of attention to its cause over lockdown.

Macmillan most complained about charity

Macmillan Cancer Support received the most fundraising complaints, but also saw a significant decrease year-on-year. 

According to the charity’s accounts for the financial year ending in December 2020, it has a total income of £194m, down from £232.8m in 2019. It is the fourth largest fundraising charity in our sample, with voluntary income making up £169m.

Macmillan groups fundraising complaints with marketing and communications complaints in its annual report. In 2019 it received 5,617 of these complaints and 4,486 in 2020. 

“In 2020, there were 10,030 expressions of dissatisfaction on social media about our products, services or our policies,” the charity’s 2020 annual report reads. 

When asked about fundraising complaints, specifically, Macmillan said that for the period April 2020 to March 2021 it received 2,144 complaints, less than half the 5,288 the previous year.

The most fundraising complaints the charity received were in regards to its Go Sober events. 

Janine Windust, director of customer and marketing plan at Macmillan Cancer Support, said: “We include any ‘expression of dissatisfaction’ on our owned social media and paid for advertising as a complaint – including comments not asking for a response. 

“We have found our social media advertising and posts to be effective in reaching larger audiences, which is also why we see a high number of complaints compared to other areas of fundraising and, indeed, other charities. Different charities log complaints in different ways so it’s difficult to make clean comparisons, and why we have higher numbers of complaints in some areas.”

Top 10 most complained about charities

Among the most complained about charities were The Woodland Trust and Cancer Research UK. 

The least complained about charities in our study were, in ascending order, Westminster Roman Catholic Diocesan Trust, The Prince's Trust, Cats Protection and MS Society. 

RNLI's fundraising complaints increased by 2000%

The RNLI's financial year ends every 31 December. In 2019 it received 1,700 complaints, and in 2020 this fell to 1,383.

Like Macmillan, RNLI's accounts do not specify if the complaints were related to fundraising.  But the charity told Civil Society News that it received 29 fundraising complaints in 2019, 86 in 2020 and 639 in 2021. This jump from 29 complaints to 639 in 2021 represents an increase of 2103%. 

This increase in fundraising complaints may be due to the negative media coverage the charity received last year. In July 2021, RNLI experienced backlash for rescuing refugees at risk of dying as they crossed the Channel. Former UKIP leader Nigel Farage called the charity a “taxi service for illegal immigration” because of it. Abuse from donors followed, with some supporters of the charity saying they would cancel their donations. 

When asked why there had been an increase in fundraising complaints, the charity said it correlated with an increase in activity. A spokesperson said: “We haven't seen an increase in fundraising complaints when comparing against the level of activity for each year.

“We saw only positive feedback for our events as we moved to a virtual offering which allowed more supporters to take part.”

Last year the RNLI told the Guardian that this increase in attention from Farage had actually led to a spike in donations. In one day it raised £200,000, which is around 30 times its normal average of £6,000–£7,000 per day.

Westminster Roman Catholic Diocesan Trust least complained about charity

Westminster Roman Catholic Diocesan Trust (WRCDT) was the least complained about charity. It received 25 complaints in 2018, eight in 2019, six in 2020 and one fundraising complaint in 2021. 

A spokesperson from the WRCDT told Civil Society News that there are  “a number of factors” that influence this.

They added: “For example, 70% of fundraised income is via the parishes, which are effectively local community groups where people get to know each other over time, and the ‘ask’ is really an open invitation. 

“Having said that, we do use addressed fundraising appeals too, for our central appeals, and have actually doubled the number of items sent out over the past four years. I think the decrease is due to having introduced a new feedback-led fundraising strategy in 2019, which has also led to more income. In our supporter magazine, Mosaic, we always include a form inviting comments, some of which we publish. This seems to have built trust with supporters.”

Cancelled events saw BHF's complaints decline

Cancelled fundraising events led to a sharp fall in complaints at the British Heart Foundation (BHF). For the year ending March 2019 it received 1,374 fundraising complaints. This halved the following year to 618 complaints, then plummeted to 139 complaints in 2020-21. 

BHF told Civil Society News that a reduction in events, community field activity, face-to-face and other public fundraising events during the pandemic vastly impacted its number of complaints. 
 
A spokesperson said: “The pandemic has been the biggest challenge in our 60-year history, with a seismic impact on our net income. As face-to-face fundraising activities and events were cancelled – including our flagship London to Brighton Bike Ride - our funding for life-saving medical research into cardiovascular disease was slashed in half in 2020-2021.”

Indeed, BHF’s total income fell by £65m between March 2020 and March 2021. In an effort to regain its fundraising income, the charity created virtual events such as MyMarathon, MyCycle and MyStepChallenge.  

Improved reporting practices

Despite most charities' fundraising complaints decreasing over 2020 and 2021, Age UK saw its fundraising complaints increase by 134%. Age UK's total income in 2018-19 was £108m compared to just over £96m in 2020-21, a decrease of 11%. 

A spokesperson from Age UK said that the charity has improved reporting processes, which accounted for the charity's increase in complaints. 

They said: “We count any comments that are negative in nature even if they are small and shared in good faith, such as one-off administrative issues, like having difficulty registering online for one of our events. We really value this feedback as it helps us to identify any improvements we could make.”

In its latest annual accounts, Age UK accounts read: “In 2020, we saw unprecedented levels of support from new and existing supporters in response to our Coronavirus Emergency Appeal.” Thus, suggesting that this uplift in support could be another reason for the increase in complaints. 


Editor's note

Tearfund originally featured in the list of charities which received more than 1,000 fundraising complaints. However, Tearfund said it had incorrectly published the total number of complaints (1,889) in its 2018-19 fundraising statement, instead of the fundraising-related figure only (687). This is pretty much stable compared to the year before (671). Tearfund has since amended the annual report on its website.

For more news, interviews, opinion and analysis about charities and the voluntary sector, sign up to receive the Civil Society News daily bulletin here.

 

More on