The more I read and hear about attitudes to AI, the more it seems that people tend to align themselves with one of two camps – they are either staunch advocates of the technology and believe it will bring great value to humanity (or, at least, are willing to give it the benefit of the doubt until proven wrong), or they are terrified of the risks and appalled at the speed at which it is invading all of our lives amid a near-total absence of regulation or control.
Increasingly I find myself in the second camp – even if I find it impossible to ignore the convenience of AI tools for magazine production tasks such as research, transcription and design (yes, thank you ChatGPT for this edition’s cover).
Of course, I can appreciate the amazing ability of AI to analyse gargantuan datasets to unearth early indicators of disease, or pinpoint gaps in service provision across a county, or spot trends in anything from social mobility to bug populations.
But we know that our use of AI is not confined to these important discoveries that could genuinely improve life on Earth. The vast majority of new data centres will, reportedly, be used for generative AI – the very tasks that suddenly make our own jobs easier and quicker, but that will undoubtedly replace unknown numbers of entry-level roles, all while drawing exorbitant volumes of water and electricity away from local communities and adding further to carbon emissions.
If only we could look to our elected leaders to help us navigate these conflicts of interest – as I’m sure I am not alone in wrestling with them. But it feels as if governments everywhere are fawning over the tech bros, terrified of losing ground in the latest race for financial advantage.
Spotlight on Corruption reported last month that the UK government met 137 times with the tech industry but not once with environmental groups when developing its AI policy. Its report, Zoned Out: How Ordinary People, Public-Interest Groups, and Local Communities are Being Excluded from Policy Making on AI Growth Zones, is shocking and should worry everyone in civil society.
If your charity’s board is also grappling with ethical questions around AI adoption and investment, do not miss the brilliant thesis by Dr Andrew Harper, deputy CEO of the Central Finance Board of the Methodist Church. It really is essential reading, both for charities that use AI (that’s pretty much all of you) and those that are invested in it (all of you with assets).
Dr Harper urges us all to examine our own relationship with the technology, and consider how we will justify it to future generations who will surely pay the price.
Tania Mason is the editor of Governance & Leadership