Social media upstages traditional debate at NCVO conference
News

Social media upstages traditional debate at NCVO conference 2

IT | 27 Jan 2010

Adam Sampson may have been arguing that the rise of social media is in some ways a threat to campaigning charities, but little did he know that Twitter was upstaging him as he spoke.

The former Shelter chief executive (pictured) was taking part in a thought-provoking panel session at the NCVO’s Campaigns Conference, and pointed out that social networking tools allow individuals to campaign without the help of charities.

Meanwhile, the event organisers had set up the big screen above the stage to display the comments of those, delegates or otherwise, commenting on the dedicated hashtag #newpol (these arrangements having been explained by an openly mystified Stuart Etherington earlier in the day).

As a result the debate was fully democratised, though the panel themselves could not see what was unfolding behind them – as one Tweeter, @Tim_Bisley, put it: “reminds me of school days and passing notes about the teachers”.

Following a comment from the floor highlight the all-white, middle-aged, male demographic of the panel (like that’s never happened at a sector event before), another Tweeter, @willperrin, opted to highlight their sartorial diversity: “panel almost has full spectrum of neck wear - tight tie, loose tie, no tie - only bow tie missing”. Though @2edinburgh pointed out that there was no cravat present.

As if the dual conversations weren't hard enough for delegates to follow, up stepped sector satirist Robin Bogg to bring a touch of absurdity to proceedings, despite not seemingly being present at the event.

His first missive read “ooooh, look, I'M ON THE BIG SCREEN”, followed by “I like the plasterwork in the room”.

But the tweet which finally promoted the panel to turn around and read the messages behind them, and which elicited a look of shock and confusion from journalist Ed Howker, read: “Ed Howker - your flies are down. I'm ‘terrified’.”

Politicians take a pasting

The Twitterfall antics continued into the afternoon with a panel session with Conservative MP Oliver Letwin, Danny Alexander, chair of the Liberal Democrat Manifesto Group and Labour Prospective Parliamentary Candidate Chuka Umunna (all pictured).

Alexander came under attack for his drones about "fairness" in his speech for the sector.

@benfolley declared: "fairness is the most meaningless and overused word in politics".

While @solobasssteve astutely observed "'Change!' 'Fairness!' 'Hope!' 'Equality!' has any party ever stood on a platform of unfairness, inequality and hoplessness?"

Letwin was lambasted for his lacklustre support for a Tobin Tax, which would see currency conversions taxed and the proceeds given to charity or overseas development.

"Question on behalf of @ActionAiduk at #newpol Letwin said no, his mates in the city breathing collective sigh of relief," tweeted @jojuber.

Surprisingly, Umunna was left relatively unscathed by the rampant Tweeters. Perhaps his frequent glances at the screen and comments on its distracting nature diverted the digital observers sub-consciously.

Share

Social media upstages traditional debate at NCVO conference

Place a comment

Simon Collister
Head of non-profit
We Are Social
28 Jan 2010

Hi there. Thanks for the write-up! I just thought I'd add my own experience of the conference.

I appreciate the article focuses on the comedic and disruptive nature of Twitter but it's also worth noting that in amongst the amusing tweets were a whole lot more discussing the issues being debated by the panel in a thoughtful and serious way. You can have a look for yourself by running a Twitter search for #newpol.

It's also worth highlighting I had two people who are hard of hearing remark to me that the Twitterfall was really useful in helping them follow what was happening on-stage.

So. Yes. While amusing, live Twittering also serves a really important purpose in opening up and facilitating access to the debate.

{disclosure: I work for We Are Social, a social media agency that sponsored and helped 'socialise' the event)

Robin Bogg
CEO
BUBB
27 Jan 2010

I am pleased you chose to ignore the serious points I tweeted as well - that would have seriously harmed my reputation.

Comments

[Cancel] | Reply to:

NCVO calls for sector spending to remain 'neutral'

2 Sep 2010

NCVO has made its submission to the Treasury spending review, calling on the government to ensure the...

Organisation to negotiate short-term property leases for charities

2 Sep 2010

Woolworths stores are being targeted by a new charity created to act as an intermediary between landlords...

CTN asked to name top five red tape burdens

1 Sep 2010

Lord Hodgson, chair of the government taskforce that is trying to reduce the level of red tape strangling...

NCVO calls for sector spending to remain 'neutral'

2 Sep 2010

NCVO has made its submission to the Treasury spending review, calling on the government to ensure the...

Graduate tax a 'disaster' for university fundraising

2 Sep 2010

The proposed ‘graduate tax’ on university alumni could have a devastating impact on the growing philanthropic...

Management change at Big Lottery Fund

1 Sep 2010

The Big Lottery Fund will see a shift in senior management by the end of the year, it has announced.

NCVO calls for sector spending to remain 'neutral'

2 Sep 2010

NCVO has made its submission to the Treasury spending review, calling on the government to ensure the...

Celebs join trustee awareness campaign

1 Sep 2010

Newsreader Jon Snow and cricketer Andrew Flintoff are among the names lending their support to the Charity...

Bubb chides his members after Newsnight chugging fiasco

1 Sep 2010

Acevo chief executive Stephen Bubb has written a stern letter to the CEOs of the top 50 fundraising charities...