Public benefit

Under the Charities Act 2006, all charities have to justify their legal status by proving they are for the public benefit.

The Charity Commission, as arbiters of the new requirement, has produced guidance for charities on how to meet the public benefit test. This 19,744-word document published in January 2008 tries to describe what public benefit is and outlines what charity trustees should consider in order to show that their charity’s aims are for the public benefit.
This guidance identifies and explains the two key principles of public benefit:

  • There must be an identifiable benefit or benefits
  • Benefit must be to the public, or a section of the public

Independent schools must provide public benefit too
In its summary of the most controversial part of the document, the section relating to independent schools and hospitals, the Commission states that schools charging high fees might have to “think about other ways that people who can’t afford those fees, can benefit”. The Commission suggests that “working in partnership with a local state school” might be one such way.

The new public benefit provisions came into force in April 2008, and from April 2009 charities will have to start declaring in their annual reports how they meet the public benefit test. The level of detail required will depend on whether the charity is above or below the audit threshold.

« First | previous | Displaying 1 to 16 (of 16) | next | last »

New charity British Waterways 'would be UK's 13th-biggest'

New charity British Waterways 'would be UK's 13th-biggest' 1

Governance | Tania Mason | 1 Feb 2010

Moving British Waterways out of the public sector and into the voluntary sector would create the 13th-largest charity by income and the fifth-largest fundraising charity, according to a new report outlining the pros and cons of the idea.

Charity Commission to assess public benefit of the Royal Opera House

Charity Commission to assess public benefit of the Royal Opera House 0

Governance | Vibeka Mair | 4 Dec 2009

The Royal Opera House Covent Garden has volunteered to have its public benefit assessed by the Charity Commission.

Scottish public benefit failures now on track to meet test

Scottish public benefit failures now on track to meet test 0

Governance | Gareth Jones | 25 Nov 2009

The four Scottish independent schools which failed the public benefit test last year have been told by OSCR that their proposals for change will be sufficient to meet the requirement.

Charities start talks on public benefit with Charity Commission

Charities start talks on public benefit with Charity Commission 0

Governance | Vibeka Mair | 14 Oct 2009

St Anselm School, one of three charities that has failed the Charity Commission’s initial public benefit assessments, expects “a game of ping pong” with the Commission over the next nine months. Today, Highfield Priory School, St Anselm’s School Trust and Penylan House Jewish Retirement and Nursing Home will be responding to the Charity Commission’s public benefit report from July which said the charities did not provide enough opportunity for those who couldn’t afford their fees and gave them 12 months to come up with an action plan.

Charities have five years to satisfy Charity Commission on public benefit

Charities have five years to satisfy Charity Commission on public benefit 0

Governance | Vibeka Mair | 7 Oct 2009

Charities could have a five-year period to adequately meet new public benefit requirements without penalty from the Charity Commission, according to its chair Dame Suzi Leather. Speaking at the Headmasters and Headmistresses conference today, Leather (pictured) said: “While we are looking for a demonstrable commitment, year on year, to satisfying the public benefit requirement, where we judge that a charity needs an extended period of time to make the necessary changes, we will be prepared to give that charity time.

Three charities fail public benefit test

Three charities fail public benefit test 0

Governance | Gareth Jones | 13 Jul 2009

Three out of 12 charities have failed the Charity Commission's initial public benefit assessments - two independent schools and one fee-charging care home. Highfield Priory School, St Anselm's School Trust and Penylan House Jewish Retirement and Nursing Home have been told their trustees have 12 months to come up with an action plan as they do not provide enough opportunity for those who cannot afford the fees to benefit.

More than one-third of honours go to sector

More than one-third of honours go to sector 0

Governance | Celina Ribeiro | 6 Jan 2009

Nearly 40 per cent of all New Years’ honours were given out to individuals for service to voluntary and community services. Knighthoods went to Mark Walport, director of the Wellcome Trust, Terrence Higgins Trust chief executive Nick Partridge and interfaith movement leader Dr Indarjit Singh, director of the Network of Sikh Organisations.

Charity Commission publishes draft guidance on education and fee-charging

Charity Commission publishes draft guidance on education and fee-charging 0

Governance | 8 Apr 2008

The Charity Commission launched further draft supplementary public benefit guidance for charities, with the publication of Public Benefit and the Advancement of Education and Public Benefit and Fee-charging. This follows the launch of draft guidance for religious and poverty-relieving charities, all of which are inviting responses.

Can the NCVO narrow the UK's social divide?

Can the NCVO narrow the UK's social divide? 0

Governance | Tania Mason | 25 Feb 2008

Stuart Etherington's hopes for a regalvanised civil society

Worth their public salt?

Worth their public salt? 0

Governance | Gareth Jones | 25 Feb 2008

The far-reaching implications of the Charity Commission's public benefit guidance

Dundee school rules

Dundee school rules 0

Governance | Alastair Keatinge | 1 Oct 2007

Recent developments in Scottish charity law

Risk: worry lines

Risk: worry lines 0

Governance | 1 Sep 2007

The results of a recent survey into what charities worry about most

Changing regulations

Changing regulations 0

Governance | 1 Jun 2007

A look at new consultation on implementing changes to the accounting and reporting framework

Private schools, public benefit?

Private schools, public benefit? 0

Governance | Ros Harwood | 1 Jul 2006

A summary of the current debate around the charitable status of independent schools

Church and state: Pope's rallying cry

Church and state: Pope's rallying cry 0

Governance | 1 Mar 2006

"Liberate reason from its blind spots": Pope Benedict's robust contribution to the debate on the meaning of charity

Shift campaigning debate on to human rights, says lawyer

Shift campaigning debate on to human rights, says lawyer 0

Governance | Tania Mason | 1 Dec 2005

A call for the Charity Commission to invite views about a public benefit test for human rights charities

« First | previous | Displaying 1 to 16 (of 16) | next | last »