Two tribes - when male panelists meet female campaigners

Two tribes - when male panelists meet female campaigners

Two tribes - when male panelists meet female campaigners

Governance | Niki May Young | 17 May 2012

Men may have ruled the political panel, but women packed the punches from the audience in the Civil Society Question Time debate, says Niki May Young.

What do you do when one of the headliners from your ground-breaking debate decides to have a baby instead of attend your event? Panic, that's what, consider crying for a moment, then take a breath and get into action stations.

We can't blame Nick Hurd for backing out of the debate yesterday - family, of course, must come first. But we did consider knocking him down a line or two in the Christmas card list when we realised the possible implications. Do we cancel the event? Do we carry on without a replacement?

No, we thought, the show must go on, but we must make it fair. So on we went seeking a stand-in. Fully aware that whoever would take his place would have approximately three hours to get to grips with what we were going to put them through - a two-hour debate on what the coalition government has achieved so far for the charity sector - we thought it only fair to accept not one but two senior figures to cover the full range of issues expected. We have to say a massive THANK YOU to Lords Hodgson and Wallace for rising to the challenge.

Thankful for the small miracle of filling Hurd's big shoes, we were then confronted by the law of unintended consequences, which presented us with a new challenge - we now had a panel of not four white middle-aged men, but five. As our Mind the Gap investigation would suggest, it was almost inevitable. It just so happens that the senior governmental figures representing the sector are white, middle-aged men. But it didn't stop one eagle-eyed observer tweeting: "#csqt interesting discussions on evolving state/civil soc relations... next debate, could we have an all female panel for a change?"

Alas, I agree! It's plain annoying that there's not more females in these roles. But boy was I heartened by the audience, almost exactly 50 per cent female, who participated with passion. And those female representatives held the panel to account on the issues that matter to the sector with particularly fiery delivery. 

Peter Hepburn, chief executive of Cats Protection, praised Daniela Barone Soares in a tweet for making the "best point" of the debate - that if the government cap on giving is an anti-fraud measure then a zero tolerance approach should/would be enforced, not the 25 per cent as proposed under the new tax relief cap rules.  

Lesley-Anne Alexander, Acevo chair and chief executive of RNIB, was all over the debate, tweeting fervently and confronting the panel with the assertion that payment-by-results shouldn't be an excuse to offload risk on to civil society.

Lesley-Anne's efforts were matched by a series of female audience members who posed the difficult questions to make the men sweat. Su Sayer stood up for the little guy (or gal) by questioning the ability of payment-by-results public service contracts to benefit small charities, a sentiment accepted unanimously by the panel as an area that must be addressed. Debra Allcock-Tyler used her opportunity to not only quiz the panel on whether cutting funding to the Charity Commission was a "huge mistake", but also to remind the crowd that Labour "stole" £425m from the Big Lottery Fund and the coalition should give it back.

The next female to pack a powerful punch was Caron Bradshaw, chief executive of Charity Finance Group, who commented that charities are an "afterthought" in policymaking and must become a "forethought". 

It was refreshing to witness such a heartfelt debate. It's the strength of feeling from within the sector that keeps it pushing forward for change. Perhaps one day this same passion will see a more gender-equal representation for the sector in government. Maybe we could start with a female stand-in for Nick while he's on paternity leave?




[Cancel] | Reply to:

Close »

Community Standards

The community and comments board is intended as a platform for informed and civilised debate.

We hope to encourage a broad range of views, however, there are standards that we expect commentators to uphold. We reserve the right to delete or amend any comments that do not adhere to these standards.

We welcome:

  • Robust but respectful debate
  • Strongly held opinions
  • Intelligent relevant discussion
  • The sharing of relevant experiences
  • New participants

We will not publish:

  • Rude, threatening, offensive, obscene or abusive language, or links to such material
  • Links to commercial organisations or spam postings. The comments board is not an advertising platform
  • The posting of contact details for yourself or others
  • Comments intended for malicious purpose or mindless abuse
  • Comments purporting to be from another person or organisation under false pretences
  • Gratuitous criticism, commentary or self-promotion
  • Any material which breaches copyright or privacy laws, or could be considered libellous
  • The use of the comments board for the pursuit or extension of personal disputes

Be aware:

  • Views expressed on the comments board are left at users’ discretion and are in no way views held or supported by Civil Society Media
  • Comments left by others may not be accurate, do not rely on them as fact
  • You may be misunderstood - sarcasm and humour can easily be taken out of context, try to be clear


  • Enjoy the opportunity to express your opinion and respect the right of others to express theirs
  • Confine your remarks to issues rather than personalities

Together we can keep our community a polite, respectful and intelligent platform for discussion.

Niki May Young

Niki May Young was employed by Civil Society Media as website editor from March 2010 until July 2013.

Tesse Akpeki (55) Martin Farrell (46) Robert Ashton (38) Tania Mason (23) Andrew Chaggar (23) David Ainsworth (20) David Philpott (14) Making Good: The Future of the Voluntary Sector (13) Vibeka Mair (11) Ian Allsop (11)
Niki May Young (11) Dorothy Dalton (10) Kirsty Weakley (10) Leon Ward (10) Celina Ribeiro (9) Gordon Hunter (9) David Davison (8) John Tate (8) Neal Green (5) Jeremy Swain (5) Rowena Lewis (5) Andrew Hind CB (4) Daniel Phelan (4) Belinda Pratten (4) Suzi Leather (3) Stephen Lloyd (3) Pauline Broomhead (3) Rosie Chapman (3) Andrew Purkis (3) Ingrid Marson (3) Alexander Swallow (3) Alice Sharman (3) Sir Stuart Etherington (2) Adrian Beney (2) Joe Saxton (2) Jesper Christensen (2) Paul Gibson (2) Andrew Scadding (2) Anne Moynihan (2) Rosamund McCarthy (2) Kevin Carey (2) Garreth Spillane (2) June O'Sullivan (2) Dan Corry (2) Paul Emery (2) Simon Steeden (2) Andrew O'Brien (2) Lesley-Anne Alexander CBE (1) Victoria Cook (1) Claris D'cruz (1) Peter Gotham (1) Sir Thomas Hughes-Hallett (1) Justin Davis Smith (1) Kate Sayer (1) Alison McKenna (1) Paul Palmer (1) Anne-Marie Piper (1) Jo Swinhoe (1) Karl Wilding (1) Richard Williams (1) Mike Hudson (1) Sir Christopher Kelly (1) Martin Brookes (1) Simon Hebditch (1) Lindsay Driscoll (1) Jo Coleman (1) Cedric Frederick (1) Jonathan Lewis (1) Dame Mary Marsh (1) Jill Pitkeathley (1) Nick Brooks (1) Linda Laurance (1) Suzie Who (1) James Thompson (1) Stephen Hammersley (1) John May (1) Julian Blake (1) Malcolm Hurlston (1) Andy Gregg (1) Beth Yorath (1) Paul Amadi (1) Caroline Beaumont (1) Judith Davey (1) Diane Lightfoot (1) Douglas Rouse (1) Jackie Turpin (1) Lynda Thomas (1) Tom Flood (1) Dan Sutch (1) Jenni Cahill (1) Jonathan Crown (1) Ruchir Shah (1) Katy Wing (1) George Ames (1) Jenny North (1) Sir David Varney (1) Liam Barrington-Bush (1) Mairéad O'Reilly (1) Tobin Aldrich (1) Michael O'Toole (1) Lisa Clavering (1) Jamie Ward-Smith (1) Ian Joseph (1) Sarah Atkinson (1) Jonathan Bruck (1) Rachel Short (1) Dr Debra Beck (1) Andy Rich (1) Ian Leggett (1) Leigh Daynes (1) Tim Willis (1) Richard Caulfield (1) Emma Callagher (1)
Less +++ More +++

The long and unhappy saga of the Local Sustainability Fund

29 Jun 2015

Last week the government announced a £20m pot of funding for charities. This sounds like good news, says...

Government can't ask charities to compete for contracts while savaging council spending

15 Jun 2015

The government cannot tell charities they must compete for contracts in a market while slashing the spending...

'Northern Powerhouse'? Almost as clearly defined as the big society

4 Jun 2015

Ian Allsop talks tomatoes and why charities should look north for income growth opportunities under the...

Join the discussion


Attending our one day courses is a highly effective way of ensuring new and existing trustees fully understand their role, responsibilities and liabilities.

>> Find out more <<