Minister denies music licensing change will cost sector £20m
11 Mar 2010
Minister for the third sector Angela Smith has been challenged to reveal the true cost to charities of...
Christian charities have accused The Big Give of pulling the plug on last week’s matched donation offer to Christian groups because its owner, the agnostic Reed Foundation, did not want to give the lion’s share of the cash to religious organisations.
The website’s funders could now be facing legal action, with one of the two aggrieved charities reportedly in consultation with lawyers.
Nexus Trust and Christian Solidarity Worldwide (CSW), who both registered to receive donations on The Big Give website, say they were told by representatives of the site that the Reed Foundation, who had put up a £1m match fund offer, shut down the website after it became apparent that donations were heavily flowing towards Christian groups.
The pound-for-pound offer was released by The Big Give at 10am on Monday 1 December, but was shut down after reports of unexpectedly high usage. It was relaunched the next day, with the total £1m pot going in less than an hour of the offer being active over the two days.
Jon Brooks, managing director of The Big Give, insisted that it was high traffic numbers and the failure of the site’s capping technology that prompted the shut-down, not the level of money going to Christian groups.
Dave Silber, head teacher at the Nexus Academy of Music (a function of the Christian organisation the Nexus Trust), told Professional Fundraising that it had initially been confirmed to him that the Nexus Trust had reached the advertised maximum match amount - £20,000 - however, in a phone call that came on Tuesday morning after students of the academy were celebrating their fundraising effort, he was told by Brooks that it was not the case.
“[Brooks] said what happened is in the first few minutes they saw all the money going out, and they saw where it was going to and, in his words: ‘the Reed Foundation is an agnostic organisation and didn’t want the lion’s share of the money going to Christian causes’,” said Silber.
Silber said Brooks informed him that instead of having a £20,000 maximum match fund limit per charity, The Big Give was now placing a £20,000 limit on ‘causes’, with £20,000 the maximum amount all registered Christian charities could receive as a whole.
“Everybody that works in the sector knows that charities and causes are completely different things,” said Silber.
Brooks confirmed that some Christian causes were banded together for the purposes of the £20,000 but that the decision to change from charity to cause applied only to “charities that promote Christian faith” and did not apply to organisations like Christian Aid which have other missions such as development.
He said that it had always been the intention of the Reed Foundation to restrict the funds in such a way, but conceded that there were “misunderstandings” as to how it came across.
“We didn’t want to have one group of charities running away with it. It wanted to be fair,” said Brooks. In the end, he said The Big Give was pleased that the money was distributed to “a wide range of charities”.
Silber’s organisation had contacted its entire database and organised donors in the UK, North America and Australia to donate to the website when it went live at 10am. The organisation was attempting to raise £40,000 for a disabled access ramp to the school and had expanded its internet facilities to help supporters donate from its own office.
In the minutes before the site was shut down last Monday, Silber said that at least £8,000 worth of donations were successfully processed through its own computers and that he had talked another donor through a £5,000 donation over the phone. While the organisation is still trying to get figures on how much of its donations were finally processed through The Big Give, early estimates suggest that all but £4,100 of the money donated to the Nexus Trust was returned to donors.
Christian Solidarity Worldwide has already issued an email to its supporters condemning the actions of The Big Give.
“We are deeply aggrieved by this situation and the discriminatory treatment of Christian organisations and are determined to seek justice on this matter,” the email reads.
The Big Give’s ‘double your donation’ website features the caveat: “The Reed Foundation reserves the right to cease or limit the matched funding delivered to any charity or sector and to terminate the matched donations at any time”, but Silber alleges this had not been made clear to organisations who had prepared for the offer in good faith.
“It is our feeling that at the very least The Big Give are guilty of total misrepresentation in their rules and promotion of the event,” he said.
If the organisation had been aware of either the alleged aversion to Christian organisations, or the intention to divide up £20,000 per causal group, Silber said that Nexus Trust would not have invested as much time – including that of students taken out of class and the “thousands” of text messages sent out to remind supporters who had pledged toward the £20,000 match fund.
The whole affair, Silber claims, has damaged his organisation’s relationship with its supporters and also diverted it from regular fundraising activity during what is normally their most profitable time of the year.
“The next time we try to run a campaign, the first thought from [donors] is going to be ‘I wonder if it’s legitimate’. There’s nothing Jon [Brooks] can do to get that back for us,” he said.
Brooks told PF that there have been “veiled” threats of legal action and is concerned that “if charities that don’t like it start suing funders then we won’t get any more funders”.
Corinna Loges, director of communication at CSW, indicated that the organisation would be taking matters further.
“I am not ready to accept the injustice that I feel we have been confronted with and will continue to seek justice for Christian Solidarity Worldwide and other organisations affected by this treatment,” she said.
“The question arises whether the Reed Foundation ought to legally honour the promise and not default on it.”
[Cancel] | Reply to:
Two new matching services from The Big Give
16 Dec 2009
£3m raised in two hours on Big Give match fund
7 Dec 2009
Top-250 Christian charity to close
18 Nov 2009
Volunteers not protected by discrimination law, tribunal rules
4 Nov 2009
Big Give match fund boosted to £12m
29 Jul 2009
Multi-million match fund again on Big Give
26 Jun 2009
Christian graffiti
3 Jun 2009
The Big Give unveils Darwinian matched funding scheme
4 Mar 2009
Matched funding returns to Big Give
30 Jan 2009
Atheist bus campaign launches nationwide
13 Jan 2009
£1m in matched donations offered by website
15 Dec 2008
£1m match fund meltdown
11 Dec 2008
Christian group wins grant to develop faith-based regional networks
10 Oct 2008
Google abortion ad case settled
10 Oct 2008
Pro-life Christian charity to sue Google over rejected AdWords
30 Apr 2008
The law of cronyism
1 Jun 2006
Belief systems
1 Jul 0007
11 Mar 2010
Minister for the third sector Angela Smith has been challenged to reveal the true cost to charities of...
11 Mar 2010
The term 'responsible investment' is regarded very positively with web surfers, while the term 'ethical...
10 Mar 2010
Crisis, the charity for single homeless people, is to merge with Off the Streets and Into Work.
11 Mar 2010
The Office of the Third Sector has launched a consultation on relaxing the rules around the selling or...
10 Mar 2010
Crisis, the charity for single homeless people, is to merge with Off the Streets and Into Work.
10 Mar 2010
A charity which assists people with limited mobility in getting access to London art spaces is being forced...
11 Mar 2010
The Charity Technology Trust has partnered with BT to offer charities the first automated system for collecting...
11 Mar 2010
The British Polio Fellowship has created a new website aimed at documenting the history of polio to help...
10 Mar 2010
World Vision has opted for a hosted two-factor authentication (2FA) service from Signify to give mobile...
Fundraising magazine
from £89.00
BUY NOW
Charity Shops Survey 2009
£65.00
BUY NOW
For the Public Benefit
from £50.00
BUY NOW
Marsha Marks
16 Dec 2008
We were told the same. The double your donation button had been removed by Tuesday morning. We are a religious group but not Christian. We also harnessed our supporters but only got just over £2,000.It was a great disappointment to us. We didn't read the small print.
I'm not sure that there is a legal case.
[Reply]