Tribunal upholds Commission's merger decision but orders changes
24 May 2012
The Charity Tribunal has upheld the Charity Commission’s decision to allow two independent schools in...
Door-to-door fundraising recorded the biggest increase in complaints from the public last year, according to the Fundraising Standard’s Board annual report.
The fundraising mechanism drew 2,106 complaints in 2009, up 340 per cent from 2008 levels, against an increase in volume of only 78 per cent.
The FRSB’s annual report showed an overall increase in complaints of 67 per cent, to just under 13,000, but this is set against an expansion of the organisation’s membership and a dramatic improvement in the number of organisations reporting – up to 84 per cent last year as opposed to under two thirds the year before. Nineteen complaints reached stage two adjudication - one less than last year – and none made it to the more serious stage three. The 13,000 complaints arose from more than 2.7bn donor contacts.
But while door-to-door reported the most dramatic rise in complaint numbers, an increase the FRSB suggested could be put down to “more members, better reporting and higher response rates”, direct mail remains king of the fundraising complaints, attracting more than 5,000 complaints – 42 per cent of the total. Still, just direct mail attracts just three complaints in every 100,000 donor contacts.
Telephone fundraising pipped door-to-door to be the second most complained about fundraising mechanism, but with much lower volumes than reported in the latter approach.
While street fundraising last year gained its typically high level of public and media criticism, chuggers drew fewer complaints than raffle fundraising. However, charities appeared to dramatically reduce their street fundraising efforts last year, with member organisations reporting less than half the number of donor contacts in 2009 compared to 2008 - the most dramatic fall of any fundraising mechanism reported to the FRSB.
New media fared best of all in the complaint stakes, with dramatic year-on-years rises in donor contacts for both email (up 626 per cent) and online generally (825 per cent), but only mild increases in complaint levels of 11 per cent and 7 per cent respectively.
Alistair McLean, chief executive of the FRSB, said that the very low number of complaints that reached even stage two level adjudication proved that members have develop sound complaints handling procedures. “Member charities continue to fundraise at a very high standard across all disciplines and, on the while, complaints remain reassuringly low,” he added.
2009, it appears, was a good year for the FRSB itself, not only with the significant increase in members reporting complaints, but with the expansion of its membership base by an additional 272 members. The organisation’s push into Wales has also paid off, with a 65 per cent increase in members in the country.
Method | 2009 - Number of complaints | 2009 - Number of contacts | 2008 - Number of complaints | 2008 - Number of contacts |
DIRECT MAIL | 5,081 | 200,392,580 | 3,608 | 53,062,800 |
TELEPHONE | 2,147 | 4,719,957 | 1,170 | 3,193,114 |
DOOR-TO-DOOR | 2,106 | 22,382,011 | 479 | 12,582,340 |
DATA PROTECTION | 1,172 |
| 238 |
|
OUTDOOR EVENTS | 530 | 957,245 | 370 | n/a |
RAFFLES | 338 | 29,799,368 | 117 | 11,167,990 |
STREET | 312 | 147,880 | 227 | 403,370 |
234 | 74,926,415 | 211 | 10,324,126 | |
DOOR DROPS | 224 | 131,296,211 | 360 | 92,490,521 |
TV | 151 | 59,664,996 | 58 | 1,564,369 |
Peter Munro
Individual
None
9 Jun 2010
I am sceptical about the validity of these statistics in comparison to the number of contacts.
I'm phoned about once or twice a week by people seeking donations or more often regular support by direct debit for "charities". Often they start with "I'm not selling anything" or "We're doing a survey", and usually I just say goodbye. When I can spare the time to talk, I usually find that the person calling either doesn't know the correct name of the charity, can't tell me what they do, or knows their charity no - they might be genuine but I doubt it. It's occurred to me to complain to the charity but never to FRSB. In any case, even though I deal with many charities each week, I didn't hear about FRSB till May this year, and I think there will be many who are similarly ignorant. I suspect that if the FRSB advertised that one could complain to them, they might get inundated. Time is precious, and I think that most of the time most of us won't want to waste time complaining anyway.
PS Siu
Fundraiser
RNS
9 Jun 2010
It's interesting to read the complaint stats, I'd like the opportunity to read more and delve a little deeper into the complaints themselves to see if any trends emerge that point to an underlying problem eg 'over-enthusiastic' chugging, wrong £amount direct debited, irrelevent/gone-away DM etc.
The FRSB seems to be establishing its relevance to the market, it'd be interesting to track progress as its visibility continues to grow, perhaps to the stage where it'll issue its own best-practice guidance to members?
Direct mail tops donors' complaints to charities
Christian bus campaign gets ten times more complaints than atheist one
A third of FRSB members still not reporting complaint numbers
FRSB looks at judging non-members too
The race is on - Alistair McLean takes the reins at the FRSB
International NGOs 'weak on complaints handling'
Charities ignore Institute’s DM complaints
FRSB requests more detail about direct mail complaints
Demand for door-to-door outstrips supply, as AAP launches Refugee Council campaign
PFRA board to consider complaints
Details of FRSB and PFRA collaboration on face-to-face complaints emerge
OCS reviews procedure for door-to-door licence rejections
Street fundraising monitoring expanded as PFRA recruits new staff
FRSB hires Sargeant to analyse fundraising complaints
Complaints about bogus clothing collections rise 200 per cent
Direct mail volumes fall, but complaints up
Doorstep fundraising recruitment soars by 25 per cent in one year
PFRA introduces door-to-door rulebook and monitoring system
FRSB to name and shame charities not reporting fundraising complaints
24 May 2012
The Charity Tribunal has upheld the Charity Commission’s decision to allow two independent schools in...
24 May 2012
The Department for Education has issued an invitation to tender for delivery of the National Citizen Service...
24 May 2012
The Charity Law Association has recommended trustees are given the legal freedom to invest on a total...
24 May 2012
The Charity Tribunal has upheld the Charity Commission’s decision to allow two independent schools in...
24 May 2012
A consultation launched by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills has been criticised for...
24 May 2012
Missing People is hoping to track down missing children using Twitter.
24 May 2012
Charities are being urged to abandon balloon releases in a Twitter a campaign.
24 May 2012
Missing People is hoping to track down missing children using Twitter.
21 May 2012
Marie Curie Cancer Care has officially opened its new national support centre in Pontypool, Wales, creating...
15 Oct 2012
15 Oct 2012
15 Oct 2012
19 Nov 2012
Simon Buttenshaw
Fundraiser
Simon Buttenshaw
15 Jun 2010
The headline of the article is sensationalist and inaccurate. The number of complaints per 'donor contacts' for door to door is so low - 1 in 10,628 in 2009 - that expressing year on year increase in percentage terms is not really useful. If my organisation called on 10,000 households and we received 1 complaint I would be quite pleased at that figure. If we then called on 30,000 the following year and received 3 complaints, I would be equally pleased - even though our number of complaints had grown by 300%!!!!!
[Reply]