Share

Haiti is an equaliser - don't dismiss the good individuals can do

Haiti is an equaliser - don't dismiss the good individuals can do
Blogs

Haiti is an equaliser - don't dismiss the good individuals can do

Governance | Andrew Chaggar | 16 Dec 2010

Andrew Chaggar responds to Rory Carroll's article in the Guardian last month calling for an end to 'aid tourism in Haiti'.

Having lived and worked in Port-au-Prince for six months I can certainly relate to some of Rory Carroll's views and observations expressed in his article entitled 'Save Haiti from aid tourists', published by the Guardian last month.

Last Saturday, for example, I waited at Port-au-Prince airport to collect our latest volunteer. There’s been chaos with flight cancellations recently due to the volatile political situation and generally peaceful demonstrations sometimes turning violent. Perhaps as a result of this, the incoming volunteers and aid-workers were a little more disparate than usual, even for Haiti, but still, they were coming. And I watched while volunteers filtered through. While I’ve seen groups of volunteers include young children, for the first time ever I saw someone with an actual newborn baby walk out of arrivals. At another point a gentleman actually stopped to pass ten dollar bills through the fence to the destitute gathered outside.

Both of these incidents were at best silly and at worst reckless. However, given that I also co-founded and now run a registered charity that openly invites volunteers without prior experience to work with us for short lengths of time, I have to say I’m also concerned about Mr Correll’s homogeneous definitions of “aid tourists” and “professional NGOs”.

Having gained a masters in international development, specialising in humanitarian action, I’ve studied key texts about how much damage misplaced good intentions and the “charitable impulse” can do. Perhaps Mr Carroll has read, for example, Alex de Waal’s Famine Crimes or Joanna Macrae’s Do No Harm. If he has, he will also be aware that “professional NGOs” have frequently done as much, if not more harm than your average private citizen.

With different organisations, I’ve worked with literally thousands of volunteers over five years in three separate disaster zones. I’ll be the first to admit that sometimes approaches and results were very questionable. However, on many occasions and with the appropriate guidance outcomes have been dramatically successful. In my experience it’s institutional culture, understanding of context and above-all a cool-head that makes the difference, regardless of NGO name, mandate or size.

Size doesn't matter

The latter point, about the size of an NGO being important, is also something that causes me to raise my eyebrows.  When I started blogging for Civil Society I came across this blog by Celina Rebeiro. In it was the following:

"There is definitely a place for these small grassroots organisations the Lancet pines after, but how does Maria Normal in Sheffield support an orphanage run by a few nuns outside Port-au-Prince if not via a megalithic entity like an international NGO."

Well for $8,000, mostly raised by volunteers, we’ve just managed to move 47 kids, living in tents since the earthquake, to a new rental property. During the 2-year lease we’ll help them develop a sustainable plan for the future so that they can live dependence-free.

A necessary diversity

Going back to Mr Carroll’s article he points out there are literally thousands upon thousands of NGOs in Haiti. While of course not all of these, or even most of them, are appropriate or going to be successful overall I would argue that a plurality of NGOs and strategies are essential in disaster zones, Haiti included. 

The wide-ranging nature of challenges and poverty here means no one group or individual can ever have all the answers. A large number of NGOs means by extension a large number of different approaches and I’ve been happy to observe some very innovative and progressive solutions coming from start-up organisations.

I’ve noted in other blogs that large, established NGOs are essential in saving lives and leveraging resources. However, I’ve also argued, here included, that small innovative organisations have an equally important role to play that can be complimentary and not competitive.

While not directly related to projects and programmes, going back to the case of the airport provides a great illustration. While we’re a small group I was personally there and ready to meet our latest volunteer as she walked out of the arrivals gate.  

At the same time two of the largest NGO’s (one mentioned in Mr Carroll’s article as “professional”), with hundreds of staff, had both left new arrivals stranded due to the flight chaos. Having offered them both drinks and loaned them my mobile phone so they could call and arrange collections, we were whisked off in a hired taxi while they sat waiting for expensive, leased 4x4 jeeps to arrive.

So before you make assumptions about professionalism, remember disaster zones are a great equaliser.

Andrew Chaggar is executive director of European Disaster Volunteers which he co-founded in 2008

 

Comments

[Cancel] | Reply to:

Close »

Community Standards

The civilsociety.co.uk community and comments board is intended as a platform for informed and civilised debate.

We hope to encourage a broad range of views, however, there are standards that we expect commentators to uphold. We reserve the right to delete or amend any comments that do not adhere to these standards.

We welcome:

  • Robust but respectful debate
  • Strongly held opinions
  • Intelligent relevant discussion
  • The sharing of relevant experiences
  • New participants

We will not publish:

  • Rude, threatening, offensive, obscene or abusive language, or links to such material
  • Links to commercial organisations or spam postings. The comments board is not an advertising platform
  • The posting of contact details for yourself or others
  • Comments intended for malicious purpose or mindless abuse
  • Comments purporting to be from another person or organisation under false pretences
  • Gratuitous criticism, commentary or self-promotion
  • Any material which breaches copyright or privacy laws, or could be considered libellous
  • The use of the comments board for the pursuit or extension of personal disputes

Be aware:

  • Views expressed on the comments board are left at users’ discretion and are in no way views held or supported by Civil Society Media
  • Comments left by others may not be accurate, do not rely on them as fact
  • You may be misunderstood - sarcasm and humour can easily be taken out of context, try to be clear

Please:

  • Enjoy the opportunity to express your opinion and respect the right of others to express theirs
  • Confine your remarks to issues rather than personalities

Together we can keep our community a polite, respectful and intelligent platform for discussion.

Andrew Chaggar

Andy Chaggar is executive director of International Disaster Volunteers (IDV) which he co-founded in 2008. In 2004, he was seriously injured and bereaved in the South East Asian tsunami, after which he became a disaster response volunteer, and founded IDV.

Follow Andy on Twitter @IDVExec

Celina Ribeiro (94) Niki May Young (36) Jonathon Grapsas (30) Michael Naidu (23) Adrian Beney (20) Andrew Scadding (20) Kirsty Weakley (18) Andrew Chaggar (17) Vibeka Mair (15) Jonathan Waddingham (15)
Suzie Who (15) David Philpott (14) Robert Ashton (12) Tania Mason (11) Daniel Fletcher (9) David Burrows (8) Alistair McLean (7) Gareth Jones (6) Beth Yorath (6) Stephen Pidgeon (5) Reuben Turner (5) Rowena Lewis (5) Tobin Aldrich (5) Leon Ward (5) Jenna Pudelek (5) Mark Astarita (4) Lucy Caldicott (4) Tony Elischer (4) Joe Saxton (4) Tod Norman (4) Ian Clark (4) David Ainsworth (4) Alan Gosschalk (3) Richard Radcliffe (3) Pauline Broomhead (3) Jeremy Swain (3) Gordon Hunter (3) Ingrid Marson (3) Lisa Clavering (3) Adam Rothwell (2) Beth Breeze (2) Matthew Bowcock (2) Tris Lumley (2) John Tate (2) Garreth Spillane (2) Liz Tait (2) Chester Mojay-Sinclare (2) Allan Freeman (2) Claire Routley (2) Lindsay Boswell (1) Victoria Cook (1) David Davison (1) Bill Lewis (1) Giles Pegram (1) Jo Swinhoe (1) Derek Humphries (1) Alan Clayton (1) Cathy Pharoah (1) Stephen George (1) Gordon Michie (1) Chris Ingram (1) Martin Farrell (1) Morag Fleming (1) Matt Goody (1) Ian MacQuillin (1) Paul Farthing (1) Jackie Mendoza (1) Max Du Bois (1) Alan Hawkes (1) Ken Burnett (1) Ian Allsop (1) Martin Brookes (1) Tesse Akpeki (1) Anne Moynihan (1) Sara Llewellin (1) Rupert Tappin (1) Julia Unwin (1) Jessica Sklair (1) Scott Gray (1) Stephen Hammersley (1) Keith Collins (1) Peter O'Hara (1) Debbie Attwood (1) Joanna Motion (1) Paul Marvell (1) Amanda McLean (1) Jason Suckley (1) Paul Amadi (1) Imogen Ward (1) June O'Sullivan (1) Kath Abrahams (1) Peter Lewis (1) Dan Corry (1) Douglas Rouse (1) Belinda Pratten (1) Jonathan Last (1) Jenni Cahill (1) Paul Emery (1) Marcelle Speller (1) Nick Aldridge (1) Philip Spedding (1) Tom Latchford (1) Sir David Varney (1) Liam Barrington-Bush (1) Jeff Brooks (1) Vicki Prout (1) Dawn Austwick (1) Dan Thompson (1) Steven George-Hilley (1) Emma-Lynn Houghton (1) Peter Horah (1) Neelam Makhijani (1) George Matafonov (1) Marcus Missen (1) Denise Lillya (1) Alice Sharman (1) Jaz Nannar (1) Ali Stunt (1) Robin Fisk (1) Gillian Claugher (1) Lynne McMahon (1)
Less +++ More +++

Putting retail at the heart of the Children’s Society

16 Jul 2014

The Children’s Society has changed the culture of its retail operation and is turning nearly 30 per...

The burden of suspicion has fallen disproportionately upon Muslim charities

8 Jul 2014

The growing focus on terrorism is unfairly raising suspicion about Muslim charities, warns Abdurahman...

Duplication on duplication

7 Jul 2014

Ian Allsop takes issue with some hardy perennials that seem to keep cropping up in the charity garden.

Society Diary: Is charity calendar banned from Facebook really pornographic?

18 Jul 2014

Our weekly round-up of outlandish and interesting information collected from the corners of the charity...

Hurd quits: The sector reacts

15 Jul 2014

Last night Nick Hurd was one of 12 ministers and three members of the Cabinet to leave their government...

Society Diary: Why is there a giant loo roll outside St Paul's?

11 Jul 2014

Our weekly round-up of outlandish and interesting information collected from the corners of the charity...

Free eNews