Carrot and stick
21 May 2012
Community isn't led by government, so why wait for it to tell you what to do, protests Robert Ashton....
While battling with the ethical do's and don'ts of donating to the homeless, a lightbulb lit in Tom Eeles' head and this is what he came up with...
You know the feeling when you think of a great idea. The one that’s going make it. Going to change your life and make you a million. Then you realise someone’s already invented it and they're doing a better job of it than you ever could. Well this idea isn’t going to make me a million. In a strange way though I do hope that someone reads this and tells me it’s already being done.
As a personal rule I don’t give to people begging on the street. Every day outside Geneva train station I battle with this dilemma again in my head. And I always side with the charities who invariably say that you shouldn’t give money directly to someone who might well spend it on alcohol, drugs or substance abuse.
My girlfriend always gives to people playing instruments or entertaining. Always. Even if we are running late and about to miss a train, plane...you get the picture. That’s a good thing. But I’m not musically talented at all and I’m sure lots of homeless people aren’t too. So I’m still left with my dilemma. The problem is after reassuring myself that I should give to the homeless charity instead, I never do. I get to my desk and the day starts and the thought disappears. So here it is. The big idea.
Pre-paid vouchers that you can give directly to the person who needs it. They get a night in a hostel and the wonderful staff and volunteers in the hostel get a chance to work with them and try and help turn things around. We could buy them online and be emailed a voucher. Better still we get a credit card sized book of vouchers for our wallet or purse. Or maybe a yearly subscription, you could buy vouchers for yourself or as a gift for someone else. Think of the opportunities to report on impact and develop a relationship with your donor on the direct impact they are having.
I’m looking forward to hearing that this is already happening somewhere or for a decent argument as to why it shouldn’t happen. Please comment below. If neither of these happens then let’s see if Shelter or one of the other innovative charities could bridge this gap.
Could this be relevant for your charity? Is there a way you could connect that exact moment of deep felt compassion in a donor with the ability for them to do something about it right there and then?
p.s. For great impact measuring could we could take a few lessons from the South West handline fisherman?
Jon Brooks
Managing Director
The Big Give
8 Jun 2010
Hi Tom, we considered this through The Big Give. Something similar is done in Ethiopia - but nothing in London!
There are a few potential risks (e.g. giving a voucher to someone who has been barred from hostels), but personally I would prefer to give a hostel voucher than cash that could be spent on anything.
It would be great to hear the thoughts of other homeless charities (well done Crisis for being first off the mark).
Tom Eeles
Fundraising Consultant
Kenes International
19 May 2010
Hi Raj,
I think the iHomeless idea is a great concept - thanks for sharing!
As I said I hoped someone was already doing this...seems like they have a great concept and need some venture philanthropy backing.
I totally agree that is sad that I (we?) don't have a high level of trust in homeless people, but that shouldn't stop us from giving, this kind of app can help take down that barrier and more trust can build from there.
What is Crisis' viewpoint on direct donations to homeless people? Are homeless charities against this? I seem to remember being on a South West Train into Waterloo when there was an announcement dissuading you from donating to beggars on the train...so I guess there is at a minimum still a societal reinforcement of the idea of not giving direct...
Best wishes,
Tom
Raj Dasani
DM exec
Crisis
19 May 2010
Some good thoughts in here but having a voucher system is almost saying at the outset we don't trust you to the person you may give the money to.
That said i can see why it may not be popular with a lot of homeless charities to go down this route and i have not seen any in the UK doing it.
I did see the below the other day and still think it is in concept stages over in the USA. Take a look.
http://vimeo.com/11166064
raj
Crisis UK
www.crisis.org.uk
21 May 2012
Community isn't led by government, so why wait for it to tell you what to do, protests Robert Ashton....
21 May 2012
How do you solve a problem like a pension deficit? David McHattie tackles the issue.
15 May 2012
David Davison mounts his soapbox to call for pensions reform.
24 May 2012
Charities, like businesses should be held to account over their environmental standards, says Katy Wing.
21 May 2012
Community isn't led by government, so why wait for it to tell you what to do, protests Robert Ashton....
17 May 2012
Men may have ruled the political panel, but women packed the punches from the audience in the Civil Society...
15 Oct 2012
15 Oct 2012
15 Oct 2012
19 Nov 2012
Ian McKay
Consultant
I McKay
8 Jun 2010
Tom,
We've been doing something like this for some years in Bath. The two organisations involved are Genesis Trust and Julian House. It's fairly low key, but works.
Ian
[Reply]